Pages

Tuesday, 11 October 2011

End monitoring of riot cases : Gujarat to SC

The Gujarat government today demanded that the Supreme Court should end monitoring of the Gujarat riot cases as the trial in these cases are going on.The Supreme Court bench comprising Justice D K Jain, Justice Aftab Alam and Justice P Sathasivam however refused to give any relief to the state government saying nothing much will happen in few more months.

While arguing for state government Mukul Rohatagi said ''..why should the monitoring go on now? When the chargesheets in these cases have been filed? The Supreme Court should not stop the monitoring...''

Refusing to give relief for now, Justice D K Jain observed ''...monitoring is gone for quite some time, it is not that we have laid down a new law, nothing will happen in few more months...'' The court however assured Gujarat government that they will consider the plea of ending the monitoring.

The court also pulled up the Special Investigating Team headed by former CBI chief RK Raghvan for changing its stand on video recording of the trial court proceedings in Gulberga Society riot case. The SIT Chief had last year in March had written a letter to the apex court asking its permission to videograph the proceedings but today when asked by the apex court it said there was no need for it.

The court went on to say that they will have to see what was the object of SIT behind this application, suppose their is a supplementary chargesheet?The court is monitoring nine riot cases and the state government wants the monitoring to end.

The court at present is monitoring 10 sensitive cases after the National Human Rights Commission and various NGOs termed the investigations into these to be shoddy and unreliable. The 10 cases being monitored are: Gulberg Society, Ode, Sardarpura, Narodao Gaon, Naroda Patya, Baranpura, Machipith, Tarsali, Pandarwada and Raghavapura.

Monday, 10 October 2011

SC stays death penalty to Kasab, notice to Maharashtra govt on his plea

#SupremeCourt court notice to Maharashtra govt on a petition filed by Mumbai terror attact accused Ajmal Amir Kasab. Kasab had sent a letter petition to the apex court after which the court appointed Senior Advocate Raju Ramachandran as amicus curiae in the matter.

A bench of Justice Aftab and Justice C K Prasad stayed the death penalty awarded to Kasab. The court also issued notice on the appeal filed by Maharashtra government. Maharashtra government had appealed against the acquittal of Faheem Ansari and another accused in the matter.

While issuing notice, the bench observed that many people think that Kasab doesn't deserve an appeal but it is the requirement of the judicial system.

Matter shall be taken up for final hearing from 31st January 2012.

Friday, 7 October 2011

An open letter to Law Minister Salman Khurshid


Dear Law Minister,

As a Legal Correspondent for many years, I have seen you many a times in the highest court of the country. I also know that you are one of the most respected lawyers in India. Recently I read about your statement that Right to information law is transgressing into the government functioning. You also say that the RTI law has been misused and there is a need for a wider debate on this law. Your statement raises many questions in my mind.

1. When you say that RTI law has been affecting the efficiency of the government, should I construe that your government can’t work in a free and transparent manner? If this is so, why should we have a government which doesn't give us a right to see if they are carrying on the mandate of the people in a fair manner? Why should we have a government which is so inefficient that it fails to perform well when it comes to fairness and transparency? Are we, the citizens of this country, there just to push an EVM button every five years and forget about it?

2. When you talk of misuse of RTI law, have you ever thought how Section 498A of Indian Penal Code is grossly misused? As a lawyer yourself, you would have seen many judgments of the Supreme Court as well as Delhi High Court where the courts repeatedly reminded government about the wide spread misuse of dowry law. Did you ever think of amending section 498A or for that matter we are yet to see the amendment which makes section 498A bailable. Another law which are grossly misused is Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Have you ever seen the conviction rate in SC/ST act? It is terribly low and many a times the courts have given findings that this law is misused a lot.

3. You talk of misuse, but recently the Supreme Court asked the government to reconsider amending law on land acquisition and law relating to adverse possession. In fact the court went on to say that Land Acquisition laws have become an instrument of oppression in the hands of state. We don’t see any initiative on the part of the government to amend that law.I want to ask you if your government has done anything to amend these laws?

4. If RTI law is giving you sleepless nights, I wonder what will happen when we, the people of this country, will ask for Right to Recall and Right to Reject? We, the people of this country are undergoing a tremendous change. We don't  want to remain the mute spectators of misuse of the mandate which has been given to the government. In fact RTI is the first step towards achieving democracy in real sense.

I understand your concerns on the misuse of RTI law, the recent spat between two top ministers of the government was exposed in public just because a RTI application revealed a tell all story.I also hope that you would have also read the Right to Information Act. The act itself provides for enough exception under Section 8 and if the government uses its discretion well, the misuse of this law shall not be a problem for the government.

Section 8 (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, there shall be no obligation to give any citizen,—
(a) information, disclosure of which would prejudicially affect the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security, strategic, scientific or economic interests of the State, relation with foreign State or lead to incitement of an offence;
(b)
information which has been expressly forbidden to be published by any court of law or tribunal or the disclosure of which may constitute contempt of court;
(c) information, the disclosure of which would cause a breach of privilege of Parliament or the State Legislature;
(d) information including commercial confidence, trade secrets or intellectual property, the disclosure of which would harm the competitive position of a third party, unless the competent authority is satisfied that larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information;
(e) information available to a person in his fiduciary relationship, unless the competent authority is satisfied that the larger public interest warrants the disclosure of such information;
(f) information received in confidence from foreign Government;
(g) information, the disclosure of which would endanger the life or physical safety of any person or identify the source of information or assistance given in confidence for law enforcement or security purposes;
(h) information which would impede the process of investigation or apprehension or prosecution of offenders;
(i) cabinet papers including records of deliberations of the Council of Ministers, Secretaries and other officers:

Provided that the decisions of Council of Ministers, the reasons thereof, and the material on the basis of which the decisions were taken shall be made public after the decision has been taken, and the matter is complete, or over:

Provided further that those matters which come under the exemptions specified in this section shall not be disclosed;

(j) information which relates to personal information the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or interest, or which would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual unless the Central Public Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer or the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information:

Provided that the information which cannot be denied to the Parliament or a State Legislature shall not be denied to any person.

So therefor, I would request you to kindly abandon the idea of amending this Right to Information law. I sincerely hope that this government will have some sanity and rather than amending Right to Information Act, the government will soon enact some badly needed laws like Janlokpal and electoral reform law which are the need of the hour.

Sincerely yours,

Sumit Nagpal

Thursday, 6 October 2011

Happy Dussehra

Please help spreading legal awareness in India so that an ordinary Indian can kill the evil of corruption 



Supreme Court judgment on misuse of Section 498A of IPC


Preeti Gupta & Anr. Vs. State Of Jharkhand & Anr. on 13 August, 2010
Author: D Bhandari 
Bench: G.S. Singhvi, Ashok Kumar Ganguly
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1512 OF 2010
(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.4684 of 2009) Preeti Gupta & Another ...Appellants Versus
State of Jharkhand & Another ....Respondents JUDGMENT
Dalveer Bhandari, J.
1. Leave granted.

2. This appeal has been filed by Preeti Gupta the married sister-in-law and a permanent resident of Navasari, Surat, Gujarat with her husband and Gaurav Poddar, a permanent 2
resident of Goregaon, Maharashtra, who is the unmarried brother-in-law of the complainant, Manisha Poddar, against the impugned judgment of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi, Jharkhand dated 27.4.2009 passed in Criminal Miscellaneous Petition Nos.304 of 2009.

3. Brief facts which are necessary to dispose of this appeal are recapitulated as under:
The Complainant Manisha was married to Kamal Poddar at Kanpur on 10.12.2006. Immediately after the marriage, the complainant who is respondent no.2 in this appeal left for Mumbai along with her husband Kamal Poddar who was working with the Tata Consultancy Services (for short "TCS") and was permanently residing at Mumbai. The complainant also joined the TCS at Mumbai on 23.12.2006. Respondent no.2 visited Ranchi to participate in "Gangaur" festival (an important Hindu festival widely celebrated in Northern India) on 16.3.2007. After staying there for a week, she returned to Mumbai on 24.03.2007.
3
4. Respondent no.2, Manisha Poddar filed a complaint on 08.07.2007 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ranchi under sections 498-A, 406, 341, 323 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code read with sections 3 and 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act against all immediate relations of her husband, namely, Pyarelal Poddar (father-in-law), Kamal Poddar (husband), Sushila Devi (mother-in-law), Gaurav Poddar (unmarried brother-in-law) and Preeti Gupta @ Preeti Agrawal (married sister-in-law). The complaint was transferred to the court of the Judicial Magistrate, Ranchi. Statements of Respondent no.2 and other witnesses were recorded and on 10.10.2008 the Judicial Magistrate took cognizance and passed the summoning order of the appellants. The appellants are aggrieved by the said summoning order.

5. In the criminal complaint, it was alleged that a luxury car was demanded by all the accused named in the complaint. It was also alleged that respondent no.2 was physically assaulted at Mumbai. According to the said allegations of the complainant, it appears that the alleged incidents had taken 4
place either at Kanpur or Mumbai. According to the averments of the complaint, except for the demand of the luxury car no incident of harassment took place at Ranchi.
6. According to the appellants, there was no specific allegation against both the appellants in the complaint. Appellant no.1 had been permanently residing with her husband at Navasari, Surat (Gujarat) for the last more than seven years. She had never visited Mumbai during the year 2007 and never stayed with respondent no.2 or her husband. Similarly, appellant no.2, unmarried brother-in-law of the complainant has also been permanently residing at Goregaon, Maharashtra.

7. It was asserted that there is no specific allegation in the entire complaint against both the appellants. The statements of prosecution witnesses PW1 to PW4 were also recorded along with the statement of the complainant. None of the prosecution witnesses had stated anything against the appellants. These appellants had very clearly stated in this appeal that they had never visited Ranchi. The appellants also 5
stated that they had never interfered with the internal affairs of the complainant and her husband. According to them, there was no question of any interference because the appellants had been living in different cities for a number of years.

8. It was clearly alleged by the appellants that they had been falsely implicated in this case. It was further stated that the complaint against the appellants was totally without any basis or foundation. The appellants also asserted that even if all the allegations incorporated in the complaint were taken to be true, even then no offence could be made out against them.
9. The appellants had submitted that the High Court ought to have quashed this complaint as far as both the appellants are concerned because there were no specific allegations against the appellants and they ought not have been summoned. In the impugned judgment, while declining to exercise its inherent powers, the High Court observed as under:
6
"In this context, I may again reiterate that the acts relating to demand or subjecting to cruelty, as per the complaint petition, have been committed at the place where the complainant was living with her husband. However, the complainant in her statement made under solemn affirmation has stated that when she came to Ranchi on the occasion of Holi, all the accused persons came and passed sarcastic remarks which in absence of actual wordings, according to the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner could never be presumed to be an act constituting offence under section 498A of the Indian Penal Code."
10. In this appeal, both the appellants specifically asserted that they had never visited Ranchi, therefore, the allegations that they made any sarcastic remarks to the complainant had no basis or foundation as far as the appellants are concerned.
11. The complainant could not dispute that appellant no.1 was a permanent resident living with her husband at Navasari, Surat, Gujarat for the last more than seven years and the appellant no.2 was permanent resident of Goregaon, Maharashtra. They had never spent any time with respondent no.2.
7

12. According to the appellants, they are not the residents of Ranchi and if they are compelled to attend the Ranchi Court repeatedly then that would lead to insurmountable harassment and inconvenience to the appellants as well as to the complainant.

13. The complaint in this case under section 498-A IPC has led to several other cases. It is mentioned that a divorce petition has been filed by the husband of respondent no.2. Both respondent no.2 and her husband are highly qualified and are working with reputed organization like Tata Consultancy Service. If because of temperamental incompatibility they cannot live with each other then it is proper that they should jointly get a decree of divorce by mutual consent. Both respondent no.2 and her husband are in such age group that if proper efforts are made, their re- settlement may not be impossible.
8
14. The main question which falls for consideration in this case is whether the High Court was justified in not exercising its inherent powers under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in the facts and circumstances of this case?
15. This court in a number of cases has laid down the scope and ambit of courts' powers under section 482 Cr.P.C. Every High Court has inherent power to act ex debito justitiae to do real and substantial justice, for the administration of which alone it exists, or to prevent abuse of the process of the court. Inherent power under section 482 Cr.P.C. can be exercised: (i) to give effect to an order under the Code; (ii) to prevent abuse of the process of court, and (iii) to otherwise secure the ends of justice.
16. Reference to the following cases would reveal that the courts have consistently taken the view that they must use this extraordinary power to prevent injustice and secure the ends of justice. The English courts have also used inherent power to achieve the same objective. It is generally agreed that the Crown Court has inherent power to protect its process 9
from abuse. In Connelly v. Director of Public Prosecutions [1964] AC 1254, Lord Devlin stated that where particular criminal proceedings constitute an abuse of process, the court is empowered to refuse to allow the indictment to proceed to trial. Lord Salmon in Director of Public Prosecutions v. Humphrys [1977] AC 1 stressed the importance of the inherent power when he observed that it is only if the prosecution amounts to an abuse of the process of the court and is oppressive and vexatious that the judge has the power to intervene. He further mentioned that the court's power to prevent such abuse is of great constitutional importance and should be jealously preserved.

17. The powers possessed by the High Court under section 482 of the Code are very wide and the very plenitude of the power requires great caution in its exercise. The court must be careful to see that its decision in exercise of this power is based on sound principles. The inherent power should not be exercised to stifle a legitimate prosecution but court's failing to use the power for advancement of justice can also lead to 10
grave injustice. The High Court should normally refrain from giving a prima facie decision in a case where all the facts are incomplete and hazy; more so, when the evidence has not been collected and produced before the court and the issues involved, whether factual or legal, are of such magnitude that they cannot be seen in their true perspective without sufficient material. Of course, no hard and fast rule can be laid down in regard to cases in which the High Court will exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction of quashing the proceedings at any stage.

18. This court had occasion to examine the legal position in a large number of cases. In R.P. Kapur v. State of Punjab AIR 1960 SC 866, this court summarized some categories of cases where inherent power can and should be exercised to quash the proceedings:
(i) where it manifestly appears that there is a legal bar against the institution or
continuance of the proceedings;
(ii) where the allegations in the first information report or complaint taken at their face value and accepted in their
entirety do not constitute the offence
alleged;
11
(iii) where the allegations constitute an offence, but there is no legal evidence
adduced or the evidence adduced clearly
or manifestly fails to prove the charge.
19. This court in State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy & Others (1977) 2 SCC 699 observed that the wholesome power under section 482 Cr.P.C. entitles the High Court to quash a proceeding when it comes to the conclusion that allowing the proceeding to continue would be an abuse of the process of the court or that the ends of justice require that the proceeding ought to be quashed. The High Courts have been invested with inherent powers, both in civil and criminal matters, to achieve a salutary public purpose. A court proceeding ought not to be permitted to degenerate into a weapon of harassment or persecution. In this case, the court observed that ends of justice are higher than the ends of mere law though justice must be administered according to laws made by the legislature. This case has been followed in a large number of subsequent cases of this court and other courts. 12
20. In Madhu Limaye v. The State of Maharashtra (1977) 4 SCC 551, a three-Judge Bench of this court held as under:- ".....In case the impugned order clearly brings out a situation which is an abuse of the process of the court, or for the purpose of securing the ends of justice interference by the High Court is absolutely necessary, then nothing contained in Section 397(2) can limit or affect the exercise of the inherent power by the High Court. Such cases would necessarily be few and far between. One such case would be the desirability of the quashing of a criminal proceeding initiated illegally, vexatiously or as being without jurisdiction. The present case would undoubtedly fall for exercise of the power of the High Court in accordance with Section 482 of the 1973 Code, even assuming, that the invoking of the revisional power of the High Court is impermissible."

21. This court in Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia & Others v. Sambhajirao Chandrojirao Angre & Others (1988) 1 SCC 692 observed in para 7 as under:
"7. The legal position is well settled that when a prosecution at the initial stage is asked to be quashed, the test to be applied by the court is as to whether the uncontroverted allegations as made prima facie establish the offence. It is also for the court to take into consideration any special features which appear in a particular case to consider whether it is expedient and in the interest of justice to permit a prosecution to continue. This is so on the basis that the court cannot be utilized for any 13
oblique purpose and where in the opinion of the court chances of an ultimate conviction is bleak and, therefore, no useful purpose is likely to be served by allowing a criminal prosecution to continue, the court may while taking into consideration the special facts of a case also quash the proceeding even though it may be at a preliminary stage."

22. In State of Haryana & Others v. Bhajan Lal & Others 1992 Supp. (1) SCC 335, this court in the backdrop of interpretation of various relevant provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, Cr.P.C.) under Chapter XIV and of the principles of law enunciated by this court in a series of decisions relating to the exercise of the extraordinary power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India or the inherent powers under section 482 Cr.P.C. gave the following categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of the court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice. Thus, this court made it clear that it may not be possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive list to 14
myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be exercised:
"(1) Where the allegations made in the first information report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose a
cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the evidence
collected in support of the same do not
disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently
improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
15
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a criminal
proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and personal grudge."
23. In G. Sagar Suri & Another v. State of UP & Others (2000) 2 SCC 636, this court observed that it is the duty and obligation of the criminal court to exercise a great deal of caution in issuing the process particularly when matters are essentially of civil nature.

24. This court in Zandu Pharmaceutical Works Ltd. & Others v. Mohd. Sharaful Haque & Another (2005) 1 SCC 122 observed thus:-
"It would be an abuse of process of the court to allow any action which would result in injustice and prevent promotion of justice. In exercise of the powers, court would be justified to quash any proceeding if it finds that initiation/continuance of 16
it amounts to abuse of the process of court or quashing of these proceedings would otherwise serve the ends of justice. When no offence is disclosed by the complaint, the court may examine the question of fact. When a complaint is sought to be quashed, it is permissible to look into the materials to assess what the complainant has alleged and whether any offence is made out even if the allegations are accepted in toto."
25. A three-Judge Bench (of which one of us, Bhandari, J. was the author of the judgment) of this Court in Inder Mohan Goswami and Another v. State of Uttaranchal & Others (2007) 12 SCC 1 comprehensively examined the legal position. The court came to a definite conclusion and the relevant observations of the court are reproduced in para 24 of the said judgment as under:-
"Inherent powers under section 482 Cr.P.C. though wide have to be exercised sparingly, carefully and with great caution and only when such exercise is justified by the tests specifically laid down in this section itself. Authority of the court exists for the advancement of justice. If any abuse of the process leading to injustice is brought to the notice of the court, then the Court would be justified in preventing injustice by invoking inherent powers in absence of specific provisions in the Statute." 17
26. We have very carefully considered the averments of the complaint and the statements of all the witnesses recorded at the time of the filing of the complaint. There are no specific allegations against the appellants in the complaint and none of the witnesses have alleged any role of both the appellants.
27. Admittedly, appellant no.1 is a permanent resident of Navasari, Surat, Gujarat and has been living with her husband for more than seven years. Similarly, appellant no.2 is a permanent resident of Goregaon, Maharasthra. They have never visited the place where the alleged incident had taken place. They had never lived with respondent no.2 and her husband. Their implication in the complaint is meant to harass and humiliate the husband's relatives. This seems to be the only basis to file this complaint against the appellants. Permitting the complainant to pursue this complaint would be an abuse of the process of law.

28. It is a matter of common knowledge that unfortunately matrimonial litigation is rapidly increasing in our country. All the courts in our country including this court are flooded with 18
matrimonial cases. This clearly demonstrates discontent and unrest in the family life of a large number of people of the society.

29. The courts are receiving a large number of cases emanating from section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code which reads as under:-
"498-A. Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to cruelty.--Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the husband of a woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine. Explanation.--For the purposes of this section, `cruelty' means:-
(a) any wilful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or
physical) of the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet such demand."
30. It is a matter of common experience that most of these complaints under section 498-A IPC are filed in the heat of the 19
moment over trivial issues without proper deliberations. We come across a large number of such complaints which are not even bona fide and are filed with oblique motive. At the same time, rapid increase in the number of genuine cases of dowry harassment are also a matter of serious concern.
31. The learned members of the Bar have enormous social responsibility and obligation to ensure that the social fiber of family life is not ruined or demolished. They must ensure that exaggerated versions of small incidents should not be reflected in the criminal complaints. Majority of the complaints are filed either on their advice or with their concurrence. The learned members of the Bar who belong to a noble profession must maintain its noble traditions and should treat every complaint under section 498-A as a basic human problem and must make serious endeavour to help the parties in arriving at an amicable resolution of that human problem. They must discharge their duties to the best of their abilities to ensure that social fiber, peace and tranquility of the society remains 20
intact. The members of the Bar should also ensure that one complaint should not lead to multiple cases.
32. Unfortunately, at the time of filing of the complaint the implications and consequences are not properly visualized by the complainant that such complaint can lead to insurmountable harassment, agony and pain to the complainant, accused and his close relations.
33. The ultimate object of justice is to find out the truth and punish the guilty and protect the innocent. To find out the truth is a herculean task in majority of these complaints. The tendency of implicating husband and all his immediate relations is also not uncommon. At times, even after the conclusion of criminal trial, it is difficult to ascertain the real truth. The courts have to be extremely careful and cautious in dealing with these complaints and must take pragmatic realities into consideration while dealing with matrimonial cases. The allegations of harassment of husband's close relations who had been living in different cities and never 21
visited or rarely visited the place where the complainant resided would have an entirely different complexion. The allegations of the complaint are required to be scrutinized with great care and circumspection. Experience reveals that long and protracted criminal trials lead to rancour, acrimony and bitterness in the relationship amongst the parties. It is also a matter of common knowledge that in cases filed by the complainant if the husband or the husband's relations had to remain in jail even for a few days, it would ruin the chances of amicable settlement altogether. The process of suffering is extremely long and painful.

34. Before parting with this case, we would like to observe that a serious relook of the entire provision is warranted by the legislation. It is also a matter of common knowledge that exaggerated versions of the incident are reflected in a large number of complaints. The tendency of over implication is also reflected in a very large number of cases.
35. The criminal trials lead to immense sufferings for all concerned. Even ultimate acquittal in the trial may also not 22
be able to wipe out the deep scars of suffering of ignominy. Unfortunately a large number of these complaints have not only flooded the courts but also have led to enormous social unrest affecting peace, harmony and happiness of the society. It is high time that the legislature must take into consideration the pragmatic realities and make suitable changes in the existing law. It is imperative for the legislature to take into consideration the informed public opinion and the pragmatic realities in consideration and make necessary changes in the relevant provisions of law. We direct the Registry to send a copy of this judgment to the Law Commission and to the Union Law Secretary, Government of India who may place it before the Hon'ble Minister for Law & Justice to take appropriate steps in the larger interest of the society.
36. When the facts and circumstances of the case are considered in the background of legal principles set out in preceding paragraphs, then it would be unfair to compel the 23
appellants to undergo the rigmarole of a criminal trial. In the interest of justice, we deem it appropriate to quash the complaint against the appellants. As a result, the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside. Consequently, this appeal is allowed.
.................................J.
(Dalveer Bhandari)
.................................J.
(K.S. Radhakrishnan)
New Delhi;
August 13, 2010

Wednesday, 5 October 2011

Justice Katju new chief of Press Council

Courtesy : The Hindustan Times

Former Supreme Court judge, Justice Markandey Katju will be the new  chairman of the Press Council of India (PCI), the apex media regulator of  the country. He will succeed Justice GN Ray, whose term has come to an end. Justice Katju, who retired from the Supreme Court on September 20 and is  known for several landmark judgments, is likely to hold  the post for the next five years, government sources said.

Contacted for his response, Justice Katju said he is yet to receive a  formal communication from the government and he would comment only after  being officially informed.Justice Katju was first appointed a judge of the Allahabad high court in  1981 and served as the chief justice of Madras and Delhi high courts,  before being elevated to the Supreme Court in April 2006. Important judgments delivered by him include legalising passive euthanasia  in India and granting bail to noted social activist Dr Binayak Sen.

Monday, 3 October 2011

Why FIR against Dr. Subramaniun Swamy is bad in law?

By : Sumit Nagpal 
(With very little knowledge I have, I have tried to analyse why FIR against Dr. Subramaniun Swamy is bad in law. Rest depands upon the courts. Let me also clarify that views expressed here are of Dr. Swamy and not mine though I have tried to analyse them purely on law.)

When I got to know about the FIR being registered against Dr. Subramaniun Swamy, the first thing I thought was are we living in India? A country which is known for its tolerent attitude towards diversity of views!

In a country where likes of Arundhati Roy can have their opinion that Kashmir should be freed from India but if someone speaks about the facts, truth, history and someone, who is a crusader against corruption, should be prosecuted for writing a so called inflammatory article?

Please dont consider me a great supporter of what Dr. Swamy wrote, rather I have a difference of opinion on many points which Dr. Swamy wrote. Still is he not entitled to have a point of view in his own country which is supposed to be the biggest democracy of this world?

Point of law

Yes! Section 153 A of IPC does provide for a jail term of three years for spreading hatred among different communities.

[I am writing the text of section 153A(a) for the sake of convenience

Section 153A. Promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion,race, place of birth, residence, language, etc., and doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony.—(1) Whoever—

(a) By words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations or otherwise, promotes or attempts to promote, on grounds of religion, race, place or birth,residence, language, caste or community or any other ground whatsoever, disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities shall be punished with imprisonment which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both]

After reading the section, I ask myself
1. What disharmony has this article created when no untoward incident happened from 16th July to 3rd October the day when the FIR has been registered?

2. Where is it written in Section 153A that a person can not appeal to Hindus to come and unite against the biggest challenge of world that is Islamic Terrorism. When he writes about Islamic terrorism, he doesn't say that every Muslim is a terrorist. Even Muslims died in 9/11 attacks.

3. Where is it written in Section 153A that one can not appeal to Muslim brothers who are equal sufferers of terrorism to join Hindus in their fight against terrorism? Is agony of a Muslim mother less than that of a Hindu mother when both have lost their sons in a bomb blast?

4. Where is it written in Section 153A that a person can not speak the truth? This is a historical fact that the ancestors of Muslims were Hindus! What is wrong in asking people to accept that? Even most of the Punjabi Muslims in Pakistan were Hindus. Muslims in Kashmir were Hindus. This a fact and will always remain so and there is nothing culpable in speaking a historical fact.

5. What prevents in Section 153A when Dr. Swamy asks for implementing Uniform Civil Code? Our Consitution says that state should ensure that India should have Uniform Civil Code (Article 44). And as far as singing Vande Matram is concerned, its the duty of every Indian to sing that.

6. Where does section 153A state that Hindus can't welcome people who are wanting to reconvert to Hinduism? In India one can see people bracing Islam or Christianity, but is it a sin to welcome those who want to come back home? Which law prevents that? Which law says that we, the Indians should not prevent Bangladeshis settling in India?

People advocating criminal action against Dr Swamy might argue that is it right to ask for removal of the masjid in Kashi Vishwanath temple and the 300 masjids at other temple sites? I understand their point of view. But just to have a wish to have temples instead of masjids doesn't make a person criminally liable! Tomorrow someone may have a laughable wish to have a Church in Macca, should anyone pay much attention to it?

Conclusion
In a democratic country like India, everyone has a right to have his opinion. Hindus and Muslims should not play in the hands of few politicians. Both the communities must understand that appeasement of one community shall lead to anger in other community. We are Indians and should come together like Indian. The FIR against Dr. Swamy is typically is case of political motivation. Some people also allege that the FIR had been filed by a person who is fighting for his own political survival and we must know that.

FIR against Subramanium Swamy for pro Hindu article

The Delhi Police on Monday registered an FIR against Janata Pary president Subramanian Swamy in connection with a newspaper article in which he suggested that that the voting rights of Indian Muslims be revoked.

The Crime Branch registered a case under Section 153A (spreading enmity between communities) of Indian Penal Code for his newspaper article in July this year, a senior police official said.

Earlier, the National Commission for Minorities (NCM) had criticised Swamy for his article.

NCM head Wajahat Habibullah had described the article as “outrageous” and as spreading “enmity and inciting hatred”.

The Harvard-educated economics scholar, in the article 'How to wipe out Islamic terror' published on July 17 in the DNA, had suggested to Indian Hindus to collectively respond to terror acts.

“We need a collective mindset as Hindus to stand against the Islamic terrorist... If any Muslim acknowledges his or her Hindu legacy, then we Hindus can accept him or her as a part of the Brihad Hindu Samaj (greater Hindu society) which is Hindustan,” Swamy wrote.

Sunday, 2 October 2011

Ram Jethmalani puts some questions for Congress’ Prince Charming

(An Article by my favourite lawyer Ram Jethmalani published in The Sunday Guardian)

After what happened in Mumbai on 26 November 2008, I felt crestfallen and humiliated. I was naturally angry against the terrorists and their sympathisers across the border. But what they succeeded in doing to us with their small number made me more angry against our government and its agencies. I was aghast at their incompetence. I resolved to record my real feelings and not act like a polite flatterer. My survey of the domestic situation and careful scrutiny of government's conduct for more than a year have left no doubt in my mind that important sections of the government are busy lining their pockets, totally indifferent to the threats facing this unfortunate nation. It will be wrong to attack the Congress party as a whole. Even today it has some individuals of integrity and concern for national good. The president, the Prime Minister and the prime minister-in-waiting are the ones to blame.

On the morning after that tragic day, I shot off my angry epistle to Sonia Gandhi. Here are the relevant parts:"Today, I am writing this with great anguish because my conscience does not permit me to remain silent. I must at least record what I think. For a long time it is obvious to the meanest intelligence that all your intelligence agencies are a complete failure and a fraud on the taxpayers. Reliable sources tell me that the ISI has infiltrated even into the RAW. Bangladesh has become a hotbed of anti-Indian activities. This requires theresignation and removal of some political heads but they are reported to enjoy your support.

"Yesterday's incidents in Bombay are proof of your government's incompetence. The names of your corrupt Ministers are freely circulating.Don't think that you are not yourself the target. The country is on fire and it needs consolation and security... Neither you nor your son whom you are projecting as the future Prime Minister of India are the solution or even a ray of hope...

"I know this will annoy you but frankly I do not care since you show no concern for the country. I have respect for the Prime Minister and his integrity. But that is not enough. I know his limitations of which you are the main source and cause.

"I hope and pray that this evokes the kind of response which the grim situation of the country urgently requires".

Things did not register any significant change. I watched with dismay how the party of illustrious statesmen who led India into freedom has virtually turned into a party of dumb, driven cattle, without courage to call their leaders to account. I was more contemptuous of large sections of the press, which had lost its critical faculty and wholly jettisoned the obligation todisseminate the truth, however unpleasant, to keep the political sovereign updated and informed.

No one could have failed to notice howmuch space and exposure were provided to Rahul Gandhi as one day the press gleefully reported that the"Baton has passed to Rahul"."Manmohan is dead and long live Rahul" was even exalted to the level ofdivine prophesy on the authority of a little known astrologer, who claimed to have glanced at the horoscopes of the two men, but had not bothered to see the natal chart of the Congress party.

I expected that some sections of the press would have the temerity to stand up and ask a few simple questions from the Prince Charming, the answers to which would have helped the citizens to assess the qualifications of their future ruler.

Some questions are too obvious. Let me give a few samples.

1. We have no objection to your mother's ambition to see you installed as India's Prime Minister. Obviously she did not entertain this ambition either for herself or any of her children in 1991. Are you prepared to take the nation into confidence and disclose the qualifications you have acquired since then to take into your hands the destiny of this complex and most populous and poverty stricken democracy?

2. Do you agree that the best available statesman in the country should fill that post? If yes, how have you convinced yourself that you are the one? We would not mind if your mother answers this question. We hope you will not turn to our dear friends Mani Shankar Aiyar or Abhishek Singhvi to ghost write the answers.

3. We are highly appreciative of the Election Commission which compels candidates for public office to disclose their material assets.

We wish they logically mandate the disclosure of intellectual assets as well.But if democracy is all about transparency, would you kindly let the nation know what academic qualifications you have acquired, when, how and from which institutions. It will help if you also tell the curious Indian nation what books you have read during the last five years; have you published any articles or any readable material on politics, economics, terrorism, war and peace? Is there any speech in Parliament, to the local Rotary Club or to a bunch of tiny toddlers with a single quotable quote that illumines or inspires and gives us some clue to your intellectual attainments? We know quite a few talented young men in the Congress party and naturally people would like to be satisfied that you are better endowed than them all. That your mother is Soniaji or your father was Rajivji is not enough evidence.

4. There have been oft-repeated charges of financial impropriety and worse against your family, including bythe president of Janata Party, Subramanian Swamy, Swiss magazines and, most unusually in a book on the KGB. Why have you not responded?

If you plead ignorance of all the stuff mentioned in the questions you do not deserve to be India's Prime Minister any way.

Will the free press look into this serious business and make effective the People's Right to Know?