Pages

Thursday, 20 October 2011

Justice for Naina Singh

Friends, we shall soon be putting the youtube link to the story we ran on India News. It takes some time. Pls bear with us.

Thanks,

Team Legal Point

Wednesday, 19 October 2011

Spread Law is now on facebook too!

I am happy to inform all my friends that we have a dedicated fan page for Spread Law.

The web address for the facebook page is www.facebook.com/SpreadLaw

All of you are requested to please like it and also ask your friends to like it too. Support from all of you means a lot to me.

Thanks,

Sumit Nagpal

SC refuses relief to Jayalalithaa; to appear in DA case tomorrow

Suprme Court refuses any relief to Tamulnadu CM Jayalalithaa, directs her to appear in lower court in Banglore in connection with her DA case

Not agreeing with the contentions of the Tamilnadu CM, a Supreme Court bench headed by Justice Dalveer Bhandari directed the Chief Secretary and DGP of Karnataka to make necessary arrangements for Jayalalithaa's security.

Appearing for the CM, Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatagi contended that Jayalalithaa's security cover includes NSG and it will not be possible for NSG to go there and inspect the premises in such a short notice as it takes NSG 96 hours to make security arrangements.

The Karnataka government on the other hand assured the apex court that they have provided Z plus security to many VIPs and the adequate security arrangements shall be made for Jayalalithaa too. Government went on to say that Gandhi Bhawan has been sanitised, special vehicles and security bandobust has been made.

After hearing all the parties, the bench observed ''...Be reasonable Mr. Rohatagi, we were also equally concerned about the security and now when the Chief Secretary and the DGP of the state have given an undertaking for adequate security arrangements, there is nothing left...''

The bench also directed Karnataka state to endure proper security from arrival to the time of departure and deployment of sufficient number of policemen.

Jayalalithaa had asked for an exemption from personal appearance citing security threats. She is facing a case of disproportionate assets which was transferred in Karnataka after SC intervention.

Tuesday, 18 October 2011

Supreme Court questions Central Govt's Haj Policy

The Supreme Court on Tuesday frowned on the Centre's practise of "politicising" the annual Haj pilgrimage by permitting official delegations to accompany the pilgrims, for which the government offers huge subsidy, saying "it's a bad religious practice". "What kind of practice is this? May be it had political use but It is a bad religious practice. It is not really Haj," a bench of Justices Aftab Alam and Ranjana Prakash Desai observed.

The apex court made the remarks while dealing with the Centre's appeal challenging a Bombay High Court judgement which had directed the ministry of external affairs to allow certain private operators to operate the services of 800 pilgrims out of the 11,000 pilgrims earmarked under the VIP quota subsidised by the government. The bench had on October 10 stayed the high court order.

The apex court on Tuesday, while extending the stay however, minced no words in expressing displeasure at the manner in which VIPs, particularly government officials, go on the pilgrimage at the cost of the state exchequer.

The bench told Attorney General G E Vahanvati and counsel Harris Beeran, appearing for the Centre, that the government must evolve a new policy for Haj next year which would be monitored by the court. 
"We will oversee the policy. We will keep the matter pending till then," the bench said.

Justice Alam pointed out that in the past the "Haj pilgrimage was undertaken by people in their old age at their own costs after discharging all their duties." But now, the government is funding the pilgrimages of even officials and other VIPs which it said is a "bad religious practice.

(Via PTI)

SC notice to UP govt on F1 racing event

#SupremeCourt issues notice to UP govt on a PIL challenging the exemption of entertainment and luxury tax granted to JayPee group which is organising Formula 1 racing event

A bench of Justice D K Jain issued the notice after the counsel for the petitioner raised objections on UP government showing ''favour'' to the JayPee group. The petition alleged that the website of the organisers offered tickets of crores of rupees and the exemption of entertainment tax is not at all justifiled.

The issue shall be taken up for urgent hearing on Friday.

Monday, 17 October 2011

Ram Jethmalani tears apart arguments of Delhi Police in Ramlila Maidan incident case

By Sumit Nagpal

Noted lawyer Ram Jethmalani today blasted Delhi Police in a case relating to Delhi Police crackdown on Baba Ramdev and his supporters during the intervening night of 4th and 5th June 2011. While arguing for Baba Ramdev's trust, Jethmalani tore apart claims of Delhi Police that if they had not taken any action, it could have led to the communal tensions in the area. In a hearing which lasted for two hours, the veteran criminal lawyer tried to pursue the judges that Delhi Police violated the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code.

Starting his arguments before the bench of Justice B S Chauhan and Justice Swatantra Kumar, Jethmalani said ".fasting and meditation are two elements of Yoga and the word used for fasting is Anshan. Swami Ramdev had declared that he was fasting for a cause of bringing back black money stashed abroad. Up to 3rd of June, Ramdev was a revered personality, not only by millions, but also by the ministers of the Government. Even the Prime Minister complemented him for his suggestions. All that turned out to be hoax and after 4th June Swamy Ramdev became a criminal..."

Jethmalani also informed the court that the owner of the property that is Ramlila Maidan is Municipal Corporation of Delhi. According to Jethmalani "..Use of this property doesn't depend upon the permission from the Delhi Police, they could neither grant permission, nor could they refuse it. There is no rule under which I could be asked to take permission. It is part of the Indian tradition to hold meetings at public places..."

Ram Jethmalani informed the court that the Police had imposed three conditions on Baba Ramdev for holding his Yoga camp. These three conditions were (1) You will have to take permission from the owner of the property; (2) Make sure that you don't obstruct the free flow of the traffic in the area and (3) Depute sufficient number of volunteers at the venue.

"...There was no breach of any of the conditions, action of Delhi Police was an act of Criminal Intimidation, it was a show of Criminal Force. Men, women and children were sleeping; Delhi Police own affidavit says that Baba Ramdev himself was sleeping. This crowd went to sleep after the Shanti Paath and they had nothing to do with the traffic. Whoever woke them up is guilty of culpable homicide of the poor lady Rajbala who lost her life.Look at the shamelessness, the records show that the people were injured due to stampede and they did not have Lathis, these are monstrous lies..." argued Jethmalani.

Refuting the claims of Delhi Police that Ramdev followers had brought bricks at the venue, Jethmalani said that the bricks were brought for constructions of temporary toilets at the venue. "...the guardians of law who entered to restore the law and order were seen trowing showers of bricks on the Kutia (कुटिया ) of Baba Ramdev. They called us unlawful assembly but in this case, it was the police which formed unlawful assembly..." argued Jethmalani.

Attacking the order under Section 144 of CrPC, Jethmalani came down heavily on the language of the order. Tearing apart the contents of the order which suggested that some people or groups wanted to disturb the peace and tranquility in the area, Jethmalani argued, "...you are bound to tell under section 144 the facts, you cant just say there are "some" people who are going to create disturbance. In a way, the followers of Ramdev would have thought that they are the ones who are going to be attacked. Suggesting the entire area as a communally sensitive area is a slur on the Muslim population there..."

Concluding his arguments for the day, Jethmalani informed the bench that the police was required to give adequate notice to people before resorting to any action and if the people did not cooperate only then the police could have taken any action. The court posted the matter for further hearing for 4th November.


SC to decide if expenditure on surgery could get exemption under tax laws

Supreme Court to decide on whether expenses for a surgery can be deducted as a professional expense from taxable income. Court admitted appeal of noted senior advocate Shanti Bhushan. Bhushan has raised the question saying that he underwent a byepass surgery saying that it was to carry on his profession in an efficient manner

The events leading to the case are as follows.

In the assessment year 1983-84, Shanti Bhushan had filed an income tax return declaring a total income of Rs 2,15,520/-. This return was later revised and in that, he had claimed as expense a sum of Rs. 1,74,000/- incurred by him on coronarysurgery performed on him in Houston, USA.


Mr. Bhushan claimed waiver under Section 31 of the Income Tax Act (IT Act) which, inter-alia permits deduction of expenditure incurred on current repairs of plant. His stand was that a human heart is in the nature of a ‘plant’ and therefore the expenditure incurred by him on the coronary surgery was akin to expenses incurred on current repairs of a plant.


The Assessing Officer rejected the claim under Section 31 and Section 37 of the I.T. Act. An appeal was filed before the Commissioner of Income Tax (CIT) against the order of the Assessing Officer. The CIT upheld the order of the Assessing Officer. Aggrieved by this, further appeal was filed before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) by Shanthi Bhushan.


The Tribunal also rejected the claim under Section 31 relying on the test laid down by the Gujarat High Court in the case of CIT vs. Elecon Engineering Co. Ltd. (1974) 96 ITR 672 (Guj.). It said “for the expenses incurred on the repair of the plant to be allowed, the assessee would have to demonstrably show that the plant was used as a “tool” with which he carried out his business or professional activity.”

The Tribunal came to the conclusion that the assessee could not have demonstrated that heart was used as a “tool of his trade” since the heart was even otherwise an organ, essential for normal and healthy functioning of a human body, and not necessarily for a professional, such as a lawyer.


An appeal was filed before the Delhi High Court, which was also rejected. The court held that “Firstly if the heart of a human being, as in the case of theassessee, were to be considered a plant, it would necessarily mean that it is an asset which should have found a mention in the assessee’s balance sheet of the previous year in issue, as also, in the earlier years. Apart from the fact that this is admittedly not so, the difficulty that the assessee would face in showing the same in his books of accounts would be of arriving at thecost of acquisition of such an asset. Therefore, in our view before expenses on repair of plant are admitted as a deduction, the plant would necessarily have to be reflectedas an asset in the books of accounts. The second ground on which, we are persuaded by the counsel for the revenue not to accept the assessee’s claim is that, even if one were to give the widest meaning to the word ‘plant’ under Section 31 of the IT Act, human heart would still not fall within the definition of the word plant.”


The Delhi High Court observed that “the question raised is the product of experience, deftness and obvious artfulness of the petitioner who is a seasoned, experienced and an eminent Advocate of the country.” Wewill have to wait and watch if Shanthi Bhushan will prefer an appeal to the Apex Court against the Delhi HC’s order.

Friday, 14 October 2011

Why Hindu youth is behaving like this?

(Hi friends! Though www.spreadlaw.blogspot.com is dedicated only for spreading legal awareness but I am writing on a different subject. Will soon create a personal blog for this. Please bear! )

By Sumit Nagpal

It was such a hectic day coming to an end when I was moving towards my office after doing the story from Delhi High Court. Suddenly I got a call from someone that Prashant Bhushan has been attacked. Immediately, I rushed back to Supreme Court to see what is happening. We got the news and everyone got something to talk about. From Anna to Digvijay, all condemned attack on Prashant Bhushan in one voice.

I also tweeted that I condemn this attack on a lawyer. But the next moment, I got a question in my mind! Why? Why is that the some of our youth are behaving like fanatics? What has lead to the frustration among our youth that is so extreme that they are ready to break law in their own hands? Why is that they are no more deterred by law? I was surprised to see that all the political parties and leaders are condemning this attack but not a single one offers a solution! Not a single one tries to analyse that what is the reason behind this frustration.

I kept thinking about it and soon I realised that this is a problem which, if not looked upon, will create such a situation that we shall not be able to handle. Our political class is not realising that we are sitting on a pressure chamber which can explode anytime.

Reasons behind growing intolerance among Hindu youth

Appeasement of minorities

India is a victim of vote bank politics. The same results in appeasement of minorities. Every party wants to encash the votes of minorities and to do that the Hindu youth gets to hear the statements of likes of Digvijay Singh. In his visit to Azamgarh after the Batala House encounter took place, Digvijay Singh hinted that the encounter might be 'fake'. What impression would this statement have created in the minds of young people who saw Inspector Mohan Chandra Sharma losing his life in that encounter? Was Mr. Digvijay Singh an investigator to know this?
What would have a young Hindu boy thought when he would have heard the Prime Minister Dr.Manmohan Singh saying that Muslims have first right over the national resources of the country? I want to ask the PM, Is the agony of a poor Muslim is better than that of a poor Hindu? Why to make such a distinction? Can't we say our national resources are for poorest of poor no matter what is their religion?

Alienation
Another major reason of rise in the frustration is a feeling of alienation from the ruling party. Whenever someone raises his voice for Hindu cause, his voice is immediately discredited by terming him as communal, RSS agent etc. In addition, there is almost no effort on the part of the government to reach out to people raising these voices. Shouldn't the political class of the country, specially, the ruling party try to reach out to these people and try to convince them that the interests of the majority community are also being taken care of? Will their voices end by just calling them, RSS agent or people of communal mindset? Why only Hindus are accused of being communal? Are Muslims of Kashmir not communal who had thrown out Kashmiri Pundits from the valley? Why this tag only for Hindus standing up for their own cause?

Tolerance
We all know India is a tolerant country, but should this tolerance be absolute? Why our government fails take action when likes of Arundhati Roy, Prashant Bhushan and Geelani openly express their voices that Kashmir should be given independence? Similarly when M F Hussain insults Hindu Gods and Goddesses, why the government remains a mute spectator? Could M F Hussain have survived if he had painted the Prophet in an Islamic country? I don't say that we should have hanged Hussain, but he could have been asked to tender an apology! Why are we tolerant to everything? Why our government remains a mute spectator even if the separatists from Kashmir come and spit on our faces in the heart of the capital? Why there is a FIR against Subramaniun Swamy and no action against Hussain? Are Hindus not entitled to protect the honours of their Gods and Goddesses? I must say that the political class needs to look into this aspect too!

Leadership vacuum
India is a country where more than 80% of the population consists of Hindus, but even after 60 years of independence, not a single political party has been able to provide effective leadership to this community. The BJP which came in power twice also failed to deliver on the core issues which led the party to power. I am not touching the Ram Mandir issue here but on other fronts like Uniform Civil Code, removal of Article 370 from Kashmir are such issues that an ordinary voter felt cheated. BJP might have their own explanations for that but the issue remains that these things could not be done.

Conclusion
The political class of this country must understand that there is a growing frustration among a class of Hindus and this issue needs immediate attention. Leaders like Digvijay Singh must understand that appeasement of one community may lead to anger in another class. The government of the day must try to reach out to this section of the society rather than just discrediting them by calling them RSS agent. And I am concerned and afraid that if this is not done soon, we may see more such incidents like what happened with Prashant Bhushan. Tomorrow, it may be Digvijay Singh and a day may come when BJP leaders may have to face the anger of some people for betraying them. I really hope sanity prevails and we become a better nation in the days to come.

Thursday, 13 October 2011

SC reduces the compensation to Uphaar tragedy victims

In a big jolt to Association of victims of Uphaar tragedy, Supreme Court reduced the compensation payable to the victims. The court also absolved MCD and the licensing authority from paying the compensation. The Court however issued some guidelines for cinema halls across the country.
A bench headed by Justice R V Raveendran ruled that Ansals shall have to pay 85% of the compensation and 15 % has to be paid by Delhi Vidyut Board.According to the apex court now the each dead who was more than 20 yrs of age shall be paid an amount of Rs.10 lakh instead of 18 laksh and dead who r less than 20 yrs of age shall be paid 7.5 laks instead of 15 lakh. Punitive damages on Ansals reduced from 2.5 crores to 25 lakh now.

The court went on to issue the guidelines for cinema halls across the country. According to the guidelines, 

  • All the cinema hall owners shall have to draw an emergency plan to handle cases such as fire tragedy.
  • The cinema hall owners will have to show a short documentary showing how can the patrons go out of the hall in case of emergency. 
  • The staff of the cinema halls have to be trained by conducting mock drills atleast once an year. 
  • The entry doors of the cinema halls shall not be bolted from outside so that patrons can go outside in case of an emergency. 
  • The government shall have to make separate rules for multiplexes.Existing system to Police granting a licence for the cinema halls has to be abolished. 
  • The govt will have to create an authority to deal with such things.
  • The cinema halls will have to be categorised in three categories as far as fire safety is concerned. Green is good, yellow is moderate and red is poor fire safety compliance.
The Association of the victims of uphaar tragedy  (AVUT) filed a civil writ petition on 28th July 1997 in the  Supreme Court against 40 respondents which includes Sushil Ansal,Gopal Ansal,companies share holders,staff of uphaar cinema & various  government agencies , but the same was refered to delhi high court. the main prayer in writ of the association is as under:
  1. Direct the Union of INDIA to ensure that no cinema hall in the country is allowed to run without LICENCE GRANTED after strictly observing all the mandatory conditions prescribed under the law
  2. To award punitive damages against the Respondents to   pay sum of Rs 100 crores jointly or severally to AVUT for the purposes of setting up and augmenting the centralised accident and trauma services and other allied services in the city of Delhi under the supervision of the hon’ble delhi high court.
  3. To award damages against the Respondents jointly or severally to all the victims who lost their lives a sum of Rs 11.8 Crores with the directions to equally distribute the same to the first degree heirs of all the victims.
  4. Award damages against all the respondents jointly or severally to the tune OF RS 10.3 crores to the injured to be distributed evenly or as may be considered just and proper by the hon’ble court.