Pages

Showing posts with label CBI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CBI. Show all posts

Wednesday, 28 September 2011

Sohrabuddin investigation is historic coverup by Gujarat Police : CBI to SC

Terming the investigation done by Gujarat Police as the greatest coverups, the CBI today demanded that the bail granted to former Gujarat Home Minister Amit Shah be canceled.

Arguing before a bench of Justice Aftab Alam and Justice Ranjana Desai, CBI's counsel Vivek Tankha said ''..investigation done by Gujarat Police is one of the greatest coverups in Indian history. It is a gigantic cover up...''

Continuing his arguments for the second consecutive day, Tankha argued that this is a fit case for quashing of the high court's order granting bail to Amit Shah accused of conspiring to kill Sohrabuddin in a fake encounter.

Tankha read out the grounds on which bail granted to Shah needs to be canceled. According to Tankha, IG police Geeta Johri was under tremendous pressure and she even wanted the case to be transferred to CBI.

CBI counsel also referred to call details of Amit Shah of two different periods. According to CBI, Shah was in touch with D G Vanjara and another accused Amin between 22nd November to 29th November 2005 during which Shohrabuddin and his wife Kausar Bi were encountered.

CBI counsel also informed that during 24th to 30th December 2006 also, Amit Shah was in touch with the accused Vanjara and Amin. During this period, Tulsiram Prajapati was encountered. Accordingly Tankha argued that elimination of two key witnesses is the ground for cancellation of bail.

CBI counsel also informed the court how one Inspector Rathore was made an accused by Gujarat Police whereas he should have been a witness in the case. According to CBI, Rathore reached to the spot accidentely where the body of Kausar Bi was being disposed off.

CBI counsel said another ground for quashing the bail to Amit Shah is threats and inducements offered to Rubabuddin Sheikh who is the brother of Sohrabuddin Shekh.

''.. This is not the stage for looking into the defence. This is not a trial, the court should only see from the material on record if the allegations are prima facie indicate that bail order should be quashed...'' CBI counsel argued before the bench.The hearing shall continue on Thursday.

In the infamous Sohrabuddin encounter case, apart from Amit Shah, the key accused include IPS officers D G Vanzara, Rajkumar Pandiyan, Dinesh M N and Vipul Agarwal, along with five lower ranking cops, who are facing charges of criminal conspiracy, murder, kidnapping, destruction of evidence and forgery.

Tuesday, 27 September 2011

Ram Jethmalani lambasts CBI lawyer in Amit Shah case!

The hearing of Amit Shah case in Supreme Court witnessed some fireworks between Shah's lawyer Ram Jethmalani and CBI's lawyer Vivek Tankha.

In the beginning of hearing there was an argument on who will start the arguments. Jethmalani said as the CBI has already concluded its arguments, it was his turn to start. Tankha on the other hand said that he is yet to finish his arguments.

Jethmalani also objected to the bench of Justice Aftab Alam and Justice Ranjana Desai hearing this case. Jethmalani said that the monitoring bench of Justice P Sathasivam and Justice R M Lodha should have heard the matter.

Jethmalani sought permission from Justice Alam to mention this point before the Chief Justice. Justice Alam responded by saying he could neither give the permission nor could he deny the permission. Jethmalani then agreed for hearing before the same bench.

During the arguments, the fireworks again errupted between Jethmalani and Tankha when the later mentioned about an internal note of the CBI which was produced by the defence as 'forged' one just to prove their case.

Jethmalani lambasted CBI lawyer by saying ''...My friend cant keep making irresponsible statements. I am sorry, this kind of advocacy is going on. If that document was a forged one, why not a single word has been mentioned in the CBI's petition in Supreme Court. Atleast you should be modest and apologise. I am sorry, you have not even read the record...''

CBI lawyer however continued his arguments accusing Amit Shah of pressurising the witnesses and tampering with the evidence. Tankha also tried to make a point saying that Amit Shah was the main conspirator in Sohrabuddin fake encounter.