Pages

Thursday, 3 November 2011

Law on bail and the 2G case

With the Delhi court rejecting the bail applications of accused in 2G scam, there is growing resentment in the judicial circles, on the way things are going on in 2G trial. But for a layman I am writing what is the law on bail and why everyone in the judicial circles is feeling agitated.

Law on bail

Before we get to know what is law on bail we must also know what are bailable offence and what are non bailable offences.
Bailable offence : A bailable offence is one in which an accused is entitled to bail as a matter of right. Generally offence which have a punishment of less than three years are said to be bailable offences.

Non-bailable offence 
A non bailable offence is one in which a person can not ask for bail as a matter of right. In fact, in such cases, it is the discretion of the court whether to release an accused on bail or not. Generally offences in which the punishment is more than three years are termed as non bailable offences.

Why bail?
Indian law is based on the principle that a person is presumed innocent till he is proved guilty. This principle governs the entire legal system of the country with few exceptions. Our entire legal history tought us ''Bail and NOT Jail'' shall be governing principle when it come to adjudication of the criminal cases in the country.

Factors which are considered by the courts which granting or denying bail to an accused

Whether there is a likelihood that if the accused is released on bail, he will abuse the process of law?

This simply means the court would see that if a person is released on bail, is there a possibility that he may try to tamper with the evidence or try to influence the witnesses. And if there is a likely possibility that a person can do this, the accused may be denied bail. In such cases, the courts may also look into the economic status of the accused.

The court will also consider, if a person is released on bail, whether there is an apprehension that he might flee the country? Generally the court considers this factor while granting bail to NRIs, foreign national etc. And in such cases an accused might be denied bail.

Nature of the offence
While in bailable offences, a person can ask for a bail as a matter of right, in non bailable offences, generally the courts refuse bail in heinous offences, or offences in which which are generally punishable with death or life imprisonment. For example in cases of attacks the sovereignty of India, terror attacks, henious murders bail will not be granted to an accused.

Whether prosecution has any objection to the grant of bail to an accused?
If the prosecution in the case is satisfied that the investigation in the case is over and the evidence of the case is documentary which can not be tampered with the prosecution may not object to the grant of bail to an accused.

Past Record
If the accused is a first time offender, this is a factor which goes in favour of the accused, The idea is to give him a chance to stay away from the company of criminals which might influence his mind and he may also turn into a hardcore criminal in future.

Health of the accused 
In many a cases, where health of an accused might be so bad that keeping him in jail might be detrimental to his life. In such cases, the courts generally seek opinion of the doctors and grant bail to an accused.

Concerns of lawyers

Coming back to the 2G scam, the lawyers are expressing their concerns on the way the established principles of law on bail are being flouted. Most of the accused are first time offenders with no criminal history. Lawyers also argue that when the investigating agency has no objection to their release on bail, under which law, the court is keeping the accused in custody. Lawyers are also concerned that because of the ongoing 2G case, in other matters too, the prosecution is taking benefit and citing the example of 2G case.

Conclusion
As a student of law and a legal correspondent, I have heard the arguments in many cases. And the present case raises questions in my mind too! Either we should change the jurisprudence or the Supreme Court must clear the air on this issue of bail so that we must know with which point of view are we supposed to look at law on bail.


Important matters coming up for hearing in Supreme Court on 04.11.2011


Following are the important matters coming up for hearing in Supreme Court on November 4, 2011

Court 1/31 (Fresh PIL) S. Krishnaswamy v/s Ministry of Finance before Justice S H Kapadia
Court 2/12 (Writ Petition fresh) Justice Dharmveer Sharma v/s Union of India before a bench of Justice Altamas kabir and Justice S S Nijjar
Court 5/9. (Fresh PIL) J.M. Lyngdoh v/s Union of India (Matter relating to criminalization of politics and Electoral Reforms in India) before the bench of Justice P Sathasivam and Justice Jasti Chelameswar
Court 6/55 (Fresh PIL) P.V. Krishnaiah v/s state of A.P. before a bench of Justice G S Singhvi and Justice Ranjana Desai
Court  12/301 (@ 2 pm) Ram Lila Maidan Incident before Justice B S Chauhan and Justice Swatantra Kumar

SC stays EC proceedings against Ashok Chavan

Supreme Court stays proceedings before Election Commission against former Chief Minister of Maharashtra, Ashok Chavan.

A bench headed by Justice Altamas Kabir also issued notices to BJP, Kirit Somaiya and Election commission on Chawhan's petition asking for a stay of proceedings going on before Election Commission of India.

A complaint before the Election Commission had accused Chavan of filing a false affidavit in the last elections where he undervalued his expenditure on advertisements in the media.

Apearing for Chavan in the apex court, Senior Advocate Gopal Subramaniun asked the court to stay the proceedings so that the matter could be decided by the Supreme Court.

Apearing for one of the parties, Senior Advocate Ranjit Kumar tried to convince the court not to stay the proceedings before the Election Commission. ''...The matter is listed for hearing before the Election Commission tomorrow...'' argued Kumar.

Not convinced by the Kumar's arguments the court stayed the proceedings before the Election Commission, the court listed the matter for hearing on December 2nd.

Tuesday, 1 November 2011

Important Matters in the #SupremeCourt on 2nd November 2011

Court 3/104. Shushil Ansal v/s CBI (Uphaar case)
Court 5/101. 1993 Bombay Blast case
Court 6/69 Gutkha Issue (Ban on plastic pouches)

Supreme Court warns newspapers of misreporting proceedings of 2G case

Supreme Court expressed deep anguish on misreporting of 2G case bail proceedings by print media without naming a particular big English language newspaper.

Yesterday the court had just asked the CBI to tell if the agency had said in the lower court that they had no objection to the grant of bail to five accused in 2G scam. But the papers reported that SC had asked why the agency had taken two different stands on 2G bail.

Warning the papers to report in a proper manner, Justice G S Singvi observed that they are in serious trouble and we are heading towards that.

Justice Singvi also mentioned in his order that the misreporting of the Supreme Court proceedings should not influence the lower court judge in any way while deciding the bail of the accused in 2G scam.

The CBI also infored that the agency did not oppose the bail of five of the accused as they have been charged with different sections. Justice Singhvi said that no one can question the right of the investigating agency and the public prosecutor on their decision on this.

The bench is hearing the bail applications of five corporates accused in 2G scam and the court has reserved the judgment in this case.

Monday, 31 October 2011

Important matter in the Supreme Court on 1st Nov 2011

Court 1/9 (pil.04) Center for PIL v/s UOI.
Court 2/21 (pil) Arvind Sharma v/s UOI
Court 3/104 (Uphaar Case) Sushil Ansal v/s CBI
Court 5/101 Bombey Blast (93) hearing starts
Court 6/40 Mirchpur violence case
Court 6/301 (3.50 pm) Bail matters of corporates accused in 2G scam Sanjay Chandra, Vinod Goenka, Hari Nair, Gautam Doshi & Surendra Pipara

Arguments in SC on bail applications of corporates accused in 2G case

By Sumit Nagpal

Arguments in the Supreme Court continued before the bench of Justice G S Singhvi and Justice H L Dattu on the bail applications filed by five corporates Sanjay Chandra, Vinod Goenka, Hari Nair, Gautam Doshi, Surendra Pipara who all are accused in 2G scam.

Starting his arguments for Sanjay Chandra, noted lawyer Ram Jethmalani tore apart the judgment of the lower court and the High Court which denied bail to his client in this case. Jethmalani argued that the principles on which the magistrate grants the bail are different from that principles on which the High Courts and the Supreme Court grants bail. ''...The only test is to see if the accused is likely to abuse the process of law or not. The trial court denied bail to my client but no where has the trial court said that the accused tried to temper with the evidence. The trial court said that few of the witnesses are emplyees of my client. But the investigation is over now! How can he influence any witness now?...'' argued Jethmalani.

In an attempt to demolish the prosecution case, Jethmalani argued that a conspiracy can only be proved in two ways; one, with the help of the approver and two, with the help of circumstancial evidence. ''...But no facts of cheating have been put on paper. The chargesheet if totally silent on ingredients on cheating. Cheating could have been attributed to me if I has misrepresented some facts. Where are they? Whom did I cheat? And if there is no prima facie case against my client, the bail is a must for my client...'' said Jethmalani.

Jethmalani also stressed that if there is no apprehension of absconding or abuse of process of law then bail must be granted in such cases. ''...Its not that I entered into conspiracy with someone to cause loss to the government, I am a businessman and I am entitled to take benefit of government policy. Was I expected to go and tell the government what kind of fools are you? This policy will result in loss to the government. The loss means wrongful loss. Which is the law that I have broken?..''

Continuing from where Jethmalani left, Senior Advocate Mukul Rohtagi started his arguments for Vivek Goenka. Rohtagi accused CBI of desperately trying to frame in a harsher section 409 of IPC which attracts a sentence of life imprisonment. Rohtagi argued that when his client tried to get bail according to section 437 CrPC, the CBI moved an application to charge the accused with 409. (Note: 437 states that in offences which carry a punishment of less than 7 years, bail is a must.)

Rohtagi also attacked the lower court for not granting the bail to the accused despite CBI not opposing the bail applications of the accused. ''...What kind of a case is this? Is it the prosecution which arrests the people or is it the court which arrest the people. Now the order has been reserved? The chargesheet says, summon and try the accused. If the CBI doesnot arrest, under which jurisprudence have they been arrested...''

Starting his arguments for Hari Nair and Surender Pipara, Senior Advocate and the former attorney genetal Ashok Desai argued that it is the right of every citizen to get bail. Ours is a case based on documents which are in the custody of CBI, we can't tamper with the evidence.

''...We have been charged with cheating but the question is whom? Who have we cheated? My client Pipara's medical condition is bad. Please release him on bail...'' argued Desai.

Arguing for Gautam Doshi, former solicitor general Soli Sorabjee said, the judge denied bail to us saying that there is no guarantee that we shall not tamper with the evidence in future but by this argument, no one can be granted bail in any case.

The Counsel for CBI, Harin Raval however tried to counter the arguments of the defence by saying that it would be wrong to suggest that there is no evidence against the accused. Rather, the court has framed charges against all the accused and this clearly means that there is prima facie evidence against the accused.

At this point, Justice Singhvi asked the CBI if this is true that CBI did not oppose the bail plea of five of the accused in lower court? The court has asked Raval to respond on Tuesday at 3.50 pm.

Justice Dattu also asked the CBI that if they do not wish to oppose the bail applications of the accused then what happens to the economic fabric theory projected before the court.

The matter shall continue on Tuesday at 3.50 pm.

SC notice on mysterious death of NC worker Yusuf Shah

By Sumit Nagpal

#SupremeCourt issues notice to Central Govt and J K Govt on a petition filed by Prof Bhim Singh asking for a CBI inquiry into the death of National Conference worker Yusuf Shah. Shah died in mysterious circumstances after he visited the house of present Chief Minister Omar Abdullah.

It is alleged that he was acting as a middleman for various politicians to get MLC seats in the state. He allegedly paid money to Abdullahs for getting a MLC seat to a local politician.

The court has asked for the responses in two weeks.

Sunday, 30 October 2011

Important matters in the Supreme Court on 31st October 2011

Court 1/47. Union Carbide corp. Ltd. v/s UOI
Court 1/53 (pil fresh) Pravasi legal cell v/s UOI
Court 3/301 Indian counci l of legal Aid v/s UOI
Court 6/301(2pm) Bail applications of accused in 2G scam
Sanjay Chandra, Vinod Goenka, Hari Nair, Gautam Doshi, Surendra Pipara